The Pied Pipers of Pluralism
Song and Verse During the XYZ Affair
By Geoff Ralston | comments |
Song and verse hold an important position in the realm of political discourse. When complicated oration and partisan pandering fail to inspire the public conscience, rhymes and prose influence political opinion by disseminating ideas through a popular medium. Unlike books or newspapers, poetry exchanged through pamphlets or by word of mouth can reach large numbers of people in community meetings, social gatherings, and even in the streets. During the XYZ Affair of 1797-98, hostile relations with the French Directory following a diplomatic fiasco threatened the stability of the new republic. With a possible war between the United States and France looming on the horizon, anti-French songs invoked imagery of patriotic revolutionary struggle to support the pro-British Federalists. Conversely, pro-French poetry decried the trappings of blind patriotism and supported the ideals of the pro-French Democratic-Republicans. This piece explores several of these songs and poems and their role in disguising partisan rhetoric in the form of attractive alternatives to open attacks against political opponents. In an age before overt political partisanship, song and verse distilled party platforms into easily recited poetry, a tradition that continues to the present day.
Read the full paper...